I just thought of an x-qatal example.
Wouldn't bereshit bara elohim be x-qatal?
"It is in the beginning that God is a creator"... or maybe "It was in the beginning that God was a creator?"
Hmmm. It does kind of change the way I think about that phrase.
3 years ago
Joel Hoffman, for whose expertise I have a ton of respect, agrees with you on this translation of Gen 1:1. See his blog entry here: http://goddidntsaythat.com/2010/04/29/clear-cogent-and-wrong/
ReplyDeleteApologies, if you've already seen this. And kudos on your taking up biblical Hebrew!
--Robin